In short
The early signs of perimenopause are often more, not less: heavier periods, worse PMS, broken sleep and a shorter fuse, long before hot flushes or skipped periods. Oestrogen swings, sometimes higher than before, while progesterone falls. Sarah McLachlan, The Perimenopause Naturopath (BHSc Naturopathy), calls this relative oestrogen excess, and it's why early perimenopause is so easy to miss.
In this post:
- What early perimenopause often looks like
- Why oestrogen swings higher before it falls
- Why progesterone drops first, and what relative oestrogen excess does
- Why the early signs get missed, and what you can do now
What does early perimenopause look like in real life?
It often looks like a woman doing everything right and feeling worse. Emma's story is one I hear in some version most weeks.
Emma wasn't sleeping well. Some nights she'd wake at 2am, her mind racing. Other nights she slept through and still woke up feeling like she hadn't rested at all. Her periods were getting heavier, her mood swings were worse than ever, and her belly was expanding even though she was eating and moving the way she always had. If anything, she was looking after herself better than she ever had.
When she finally asked whether this could be perimenopause, the answer was: "You're too young. Your periods are still regular, and you don't have hot flushes. This is probably just stress."
Sound familiar? That answer rests on an outdated picture of perimenopause, one where it starts with hot flushes and skipped periods.
From my clinic: the most common early picture I see isn't a hot flush. It's heavier periods, worse PMS and 2am waking, all turning up in the same few months.
What are the early signs of perimenopause?
The early signs of perimenopause are usually more of something, not less. Most of us were taught to wait for fewer periods, then hot flushes. Early on, it's often the opposite:
- heavier or more painful periods, or periods coming closer together
- PMS that's worse than it's ever been, with bloating and sore breasts
- waking at 2am or 3am when you used to sleep through
- a shorter fuse, or anxiety that feels new
- new reactions to foods, drinks or scents, and more headaches
None of these on its own means it's perimenopause. Several of them, changing together over a few months, is a pattern worth taking seriously, whatever your age.
Prefer to watch? I walk through the early signs, and what "too young" really means, in this video.
Why does oestrogen swing higher before it falls?
Because in early perimenopause your ovaries respond less predictably, so oestrogen stops following its old monthly rhythm and swings up and down instead [1, 3]. In your 20s and 30s, oestrogen rose through the first half of your cycle, peaked around ovulation, then settled, in a pattern your body was used to. In perimenopause that rhythm breaks down. Some cycles, oestrogen surges higher than you're used to. Others, it drops low. It does fall for good eventually, but it gets there on a rollercoaster, not a slope.
That's why you can feel fine one moment and blindsided the next: high-oestrogen days and low-oestrogen days bring different symptoms (see the table below).
From my clinic: when a woman tells me she feels like a different person from one week to the next, the first thing I look at is what's happening with her cycle.
Why does progesterone fall first?
Progesterone falls first because it's only made after you ovulate, and in perimenopause you ovulate less reliably [3, 4]. No ovulation means little or no progesterone that cycle. Even when you do ovulate, the amount made after ovulation can be lower than it was [4].
Progesterone is your calming hormone. It supports sleep, takes the edge off stress, and acts as the counterweight to oestrogen. When it drops, you can feel more anxious, more reactive and less able to handle a busy week, and you might wake at 3am with your heart pounding for no obvious reason. That's not a resilience problem. That's physiology.
What is relative oestrogen excess?
Relative oestrogen excess means oestrogen is high compared with progesterone, even if your oestrogen isn't high on paper. Oestrogen is swinging on its way down, but progesterone is falling faster, so the ratio between them tips. You can have relative oestrogen excess even close to menopause.
It drives some of the most frustrating early symptoms. Without enough progesterone to calm your nervous system, PMS and irritability get worse. Higher oestrogen builds a thicker uterine lining, so periods can get heavier and more painful (more on that in heavy bleeding in perimenopause). And higher oestrogen drives histamine up while progesterone's calming counterweight drops, which is why new allergies, intolerances and headaches can appear (histamine and perimenopause).
| What's happening | What it can feel like |
|---|---|
| Oestrogen running high | Heavier, more painful periods; bloating and sore breasts; irritability and anxiety; new reactions to foods or scents |
| Oestrogen dropping low | Brain fog and forgetfulness; tiredness; waking unrefreshed |
| Progesterone falling | 2am or 3am waking; a shorter fuse; stress that feels harder to handle; worse PMS |
Early perimenopause
More, not less
Oestrogen swings, sometimes higher than before,
while progesterone falls.
Swings up and down, sometimes higher than before
Falls as ovulation gets less regular
The tip: relative oestrogen excess
What it can feel like
Heavier periods
Worse PMS
2am waking
Bloating and sore breasts
A shorter fuse
New reactions to foods or scents
If you're waiting for a hot flush,
you could be waiting a while.
Common doesn't mean normal.
Can you get hot flushes while your periods are still regular?
Yes, you can. Hot flushes and night sweats are driven by changing oestrogen [1], not by your periods stopping, so they can appear in your late 30s and early 40s while your cycle is still regular. For most women, though, they're more common in mid to late perimenopause, once periods start spacing out. That's why using hot flushes as the starting line misses so many women. If you're waiting for the flushes before you take it seriously, you could be waiting a while. What causes them, and what helps, is in hot flushes in perimenopause.
Why are the early signs of perimenopause so often missed?
Because the picture most of us were given is out of date. It says perimenopause is a slow decline in oestrogen that shows up as hot flushes and skipped periods. Early perimenopause is the opposite: hormone swings, more symptoms, and periods that are often still regular.
So women in their late 30s and 40s are told they're too young, or that it's stress, or to eat less and move more when their weight shifts. In Australia perimenopause usually starts around 47, and the average age of menopause is 51 [1]. But an average is the middle, not the minimum: around 1 in 10 women go through menopause before 45, which means their perimenopause started earlier still [2]. Many more reach menopause at 45 or 46, and for them perimenopause can start in their late 30s or early 40s. Being told you're too young usually means you're younger than average. How perimenopause is recognised, and whether you can be too young, explains what to track and ask.
"Early perimenopause usually isn't less of anything. It's more. More PMS, heavier periods, more 2am wake-ups. If you're waiting for a hot flush before you take it seriously, you could lose years you don't need to lose." ~ Sarah McLachlan, The Perimenopause Naturopath (BHSc Naturopathy), Eden Hills, Adelaide
If you've been told it's just stress, you're not imagining things. Common doesn't mean normal, and this phase has a name.
What can you do about early perimenopause symptoms now?
You don't have to wait for irregular periods or hot flushes to start supporting your body. Start with what's actually changing:
- Track the pattern. Two to three months of notes on your cycle, sleep, mood and energy says far more than one bad week. The diagnosis post has the list.
- Look after progesterone's jobs. Protect sleep, keep blood sugar more even with protein at breakfast, and lighten the stress load where you can, because a body running on cortisol has less room to adapt.
- Help your body clear oestrogen. Fibre, vegetables and regular bowel motions all help your body move used oestrogen out. Ground flaxseed is one I often start with for the oestrogen rollercoaster.
- Go easy on alcohol, which adds to the histamine load.
- Ask your doctor to check your iron if your periods are heavier, and your thyroid if you're exhausted.
From my clinic: most women I see have been eating "well" for years. The problem isn't effort. It's using a strategy that was built for a body that isn't changing.
When to see your doctor
Heavier periods are common in perimenopause, but they still need checking. See your doctor if you're soaking through a pad or tampon every hour or two, or bleeding for longer than 8 days. Bleeding between periods, after sex, or after your periods have stopped for 12 months needs a check too. See your doctor too if you feel faint, short of breath, have a pounding heart or palpitations, or feel unusually tired, which can be a sign of low iron. This post is general information, not a diagnosis.
Want a plan for this phase, not just a name for it?
Knowing it's perimenopause is the start. Knowing what to eat, drink and do about it is the part that changes how you feel. That's what I teach in PerimenoGO, my self-paced foundations program. You'll understand why your body's doing what it's doing, and you'll know the foundations to support it, so you're not trying the next thing off Instagram.
Frequently asked questions
Can you have high oestrogen in perimenopause?
Yes. Early in perimenopause, oestrogen swings up and down, and some cycles it runs higher than you're used to. Because progesterone is falling at the same time, oestrogen can also be high compared with progesterone, which is called relative oestrogen excess. That's behind a lot of early symptoms, like heavier periods and worse PMS.
Can perimenopause start with heavier periods?
Yes, and for many women it does. Higher oestrogen with less progesterone builds a thicker uterine lining, so periods can get heavier and more painful before they ever get lighter. Very heavy bleeding still needs a check with your doctor, including your iron.
Why do I feel fine one week and awful the next in perimenopause?
Because your hormones are no longer following a predictable monthly pattern. Oestrogen can be high one week and low the next, and progesterone may be missing in cycles where you don't ovulate. Each shift brings its own symptoms, which is why it can feel random when it isn't.
Is relative oestrogen excess the same as oestrogen dominance?
They describe the same idea: oestrogen that's high compared with progesterone. I say relative oestrogen excess, because it's about the ratio, and your oestrogen can be normal or even low on a blood test while it's still happening.
References
- Jean Hailes for Women's Health. Menopause. jeanhailes.org.au
- Jean Hailes for Women's Health. Premature and early menopause. jeanhailes.org.au
- Hale GE, Robertson DM, Burger HG. The perimenopausal woman: endocrinology and management. J Steroid Biochem Mol Biol. 2014;142:121-31. doi.org/10.1016/j.jsbmb.2013.08.015
- Robertson DM, Hale GE, Fraser IS, Hughes CL, Burger HG. A proposed classification system for menstrual cycles in the menopause transition based on changes in serum hormone profiles. Menopause. 2008;15(6):1139-44. doi.org/10.1097/gme.0b013e3181735687
Emma's story is shared with her permission.
ARTICLE/CONTENT DISCLAIMER
The information provided in this blog is for personal or other non-commercial, educational purposes. It should not be considered medical or professional advice. We recommend consulting a qualified healthcare professional before taking or omitting any action based on this content. While the author uses best endeavours to provide accurate and true content, the author makes no guarantees or promises and assumes no liability regarding the accuracy, reliability or completeness of the information presented. The information, opinions, and recommendations provided are for general information only, and any reliance on this content is done at your own risk.
Any third-party materials or external content referenced in this blog do not necessarily reflect the author's opinion, standards or policies and the author assumes no liability for them.






0 Comments